Title

Postscript: winnowing out some take-home points.

Date of Original Version

10-1-2009

Type

Response or Comment

PubMed ID

19839697

Abstract or Description

Presents a postscript to the current authors' response (see record 2009-18254-016) to the comments by J. S. Bowers, M. F. Damian, and C. J. Davis (see records 2009-18254-015and 2009-18254-017) on the current authors' original article, "Short-term memory for serial order: A recurrent neural network model," (see record 2006-04733-001). Here, Botvinick and Plaut address Bowers et al's assertions that neurophysiological studies that have reported conjunctive coding for item and order have also often reported neurons that code for item independent of order and vice versa, and that the primacy model of Page and Norris (1998) uses order-independent item representations. Botvinick and Plaut then consider the two new simulations that Bowers et al presented in their commentary, ultimately concluding that the critique by Bowers et al does little to challenge the viability of the Botvinick and Plaut model.

DOI

10.1037/0033-295X.116.4.1001

 

Published In

Psychological review, 116, 4, 1001-1002.